Shakespeares shylock a villain or victim

This is compelling material, and with its careful structure, and an actor as skilled as Guy Masterson, it is displayed to the fullest advantage: The following bond proves this.

Masterson is funny and poignant, physical and quiet and through it all we are given a performance that places Shylock in the Shakespeares shylock a villain or victim created for him by history, by other characters and by our responses to him.

Armstrong conveys to us the idea that Shylock's unreasonable and unrelenting demand for his 'pound of flesh' is not indicative of Shakespeare's anti-Semitism, rather a comment on the extreme behaviours that can result when a minority is shunned, ignored and ridiculed. He is outraged that she has left and has stolen his money.

Guy Masterson, perhaps the world's leading exponent of the form, demonstrates its brilliance, honouring one of Shakespeare's finest creations from one of his greatest plays in a performance that celebrates the beauty of language, the power of history and the magic of theatre!

Somehow, in just an hour and a quarter, the script covers the important elements of Shylock's story in Shakespeare's play as well as years of the play's production and 2, years of Jewish persecution. It was with this very cool serendipitous footnote in New Zealand theatre history in the back of my mind that I went to Masterson's performances of Under Milk Wood and Shylock, alternating this week at the Herald.

Amazingly, by first reading the story 'pinched' by Shakespeare from a 14th century folktale, then enacting all of Shylock's key scenes, Masterson succeeds in giving us the essence of The Merchant of Venice.

There's a whole subset of the Shakespeare industry dedicated to shows from the point of view of minor characters most famously Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, and Tim Crouch came here last year with I, Peaseblossomand Shylock is a worthy contribution.

Shylock could be considered to be very cold and brutal towards to his only daughter. What does it mean to be Shylock, at once the villain and the victim, and the star of his play; what does it mean to be any Jew throughout history?

The sparse staging and minimal use of props, including a box of Shylock's costumes and a backdrop containing the word "Jew" in several languages, allows the audience to focus on Tubal.

The hooked nose, wild hair and cunning eyes of anti-Semitic caricature might have originated on the Renaissance stage; later in the play, Masterson dons a large-nosed Venetian mask and unruly red wig to recite Shylock's famous "Hath not a Jew eyes?

He his humiliated and dehumanised even more. It all adds up to a sumptuous theatrical, historical and intellectual feast served up in a bravura performance. His appearance was hardly noticeable and his entrance was slightly delayed.

Playing to an absolutely full house, Guy Masterson takes us on an amazing journey through the history of anti-Semitism using the vehicle of Shakespeare's Shylock and narrated by TubalShylock's only friend.

In Act 3 Scene 3, Shylock is beyond all reasoning, and is almost sadistic. It's a sprightly performance too, bringing visual interest to a relatively bare stage - though three hanging banners, covered with the word 'Jew' translated into dozens of languages, serve as a constant reminder of just what this play is all about.

It is the engaging qualities of Masterson's self-deprecating Tubal who holds these interlaced narratives together, allowing us to dip in and out of history as to when it is relevant pertaining to Shylock's speeches.

Is Shylock A Villain Or A Victim

Some of the history is sobering: Belmont is a very effeminate place where there is no money-lending etc. Actually it makes for an exciting and complete theatre experience.

I agree with Sir Peter Hall that he is a very complex character, and that is what makes him an interesting character. The Fortune Theatre has provided solid technical support, Masterson simply giving the crew instructions, and the occasional wink, when he wants some variation in the lighting and sound effects, like the subtle enhancement of chanting for church or synagogue, while set and costume are simple and functional.

The premise - like the set, sound and lighting design - is simple but used to great effect: It's a sprightly performance too, bringing visual interest to a relatively bare stage - though three hanging banners, covered with the word 'Jew' translated into dozens of languages, serve as a constant reminder of just what this play is all about.

DH Lawrence wrote astutely about what happens to a living work when the artist puts his finger in the pan, forcing its outcome.

Shunning the obvious choice of Shylock himself as narrator, the playwright has shrewdly opted for the slightly resentful actor who is given the bit-part of Shylock's sidekick, Tubal: It is cleverly written and superbly performed, even John Knox would have enjoyed it.

Is Shylock a villain or victim in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice Essay

Bassanio who arrives within the hour, immediately offers Shylock six thousand ducats, twice the amount of the original finance but Shylock declines the offer and only says that he would not give in to money only to dish his revenge out on Antonio.

The differences between the two are instructive, because while Armstrong inhabited the character, Masterson always - deliberately - remains a little outside him.

Masterson's heartfelt love for all the flawed aspects of humanity make this a warm and memorable evening.

Villain or victim, Shakespeare’s Shylock is a character to celebrate

It's important context for interpreting the more problematic aspects of Shakespeare's text; and there are other analytical strands as well, unpicking some of the implications and meanings that might pass a modern audience by. Furthermore Shylocks hatred for Antonio can also build up the dislike to Christians due to the fact that Antonio himself is a Christian, which portrays Shylock as narrow-minded, a characteristic associated with archetypical villains.

This is what seems to happen with Shylock and Antonio. As well as being a vindication of Shylock's desire for vengeance, given the history of his people, this play is an affectionate tribute to the acting profession, its insight and courage as well as its vanity and absurdity.

However, the main reason for rushing to Assembly Hall is to see Guy Masterson, under the direction of the writer, who has himself performed the monologue around the globe, affectionately playing Shylock but also those around him.

Shunning the obvious choice of Shylock himself as narrator, the playwright has shrewdly opted for the slightly resentful actor who is given the bit-part of Shylock's sidekick, Tubal: Shylock's daughter being the only other Jew He reminds us that Shakespeare would not have met any Jews - not any who were legally present, anyway, because Jews had been barred from England for centuries, following the upsurge of the blood libel, of the idea of Jews using Christian children in rituals, in the 12th century.

The rest of the speech tries to make the Christians feel guilty, and I think it makes him look the victim again.Shylock as a Villian or Victim in The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare The Merchant Of Venice is the story of Antonio, a merchant, borrowing money from Shylock, a Jewish moneylender, in order to fund his best friend Bassanio’s romantic ambitions.

Is Shylock a villain or victim in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice Essay. The overall climax of this play is brilliantly displayed because the realism of the discrimination and prejudice towards Jews helps us to develop a sympathetic feeling for them.

In this side of the story; Shakespeare has made it majorly difficult to decide whether he’s acting a victim or villain here; reading it the first time I thought he was a villain, but after putting myself in Shylock’s position, he shows signs of being what truly a human would be like, how a human would react, and in the Elizabethan era, Jews.

Was Shylock a Victim or a Villain Essay

Shylock has always divided opinion. Is he a villain or a victim? Or is he someone even more intriguing? There is no doubt Shylock is hard done by in "The Merchant of Venice", but does he bring it on himself?As one of only two Jewish men in the whole of Shakespeare, he has been portrayed in ways which reflected how Jews were popularly viewed - from comic villain in Shakespeare's day to a victim.

Shylock has always divided opinion. Is he a villain or a victim? Or is he someone even more intriguing? There is no doubt Shylock is hard done by in "The Merchant of Venice", but does he bring it on himself?As one of only two Jewish men in the whole of Shakespeare, he has been portrayed in ways which reflected how Jews were popularly viewed - from comic villain in Shakespeare's day to a victim.

- Shylock: Victim or Villain "The Merchant of Venice" by Shakespeare is set in the Italian city of Venice in the late 15th century.

Shylock: Victim or Villain Essay

Originally, it was meant to be a comedy but it seems to have more elements of a tragedy than of a comedy.

Download
Shakespeares shylock a villain or victim
Rated 3/5 based on 83 review