An analysis of the topic of abortion and the morally just killing

Premise An action is good insofar as it helps to satisfy desire. Egalitarian critics of classical utilitarianism argue that the latter outcome is better, so more than the total amount of good matters.

Moral realism is the class of theories which hold that there are true moral statements that report objective moral facts. The Japanese are not planning to relinquish Hokkaido to its original owners, the Ainu. In order to do so the State will have to right many wrongs.

Hence consequentialism is opposed to common sense and is probably wrong.

Guns And States

To keep a big secret, you must actively mislead and deceive people and keep them at a distance. For example, suppose that many years ago, before anyone knew that gold is made of atoms or that it is the element with atomic number 79, Jack and Jill were hiking in unclaimed land and came upon some heavy shiny lumps.

It seems likely that the same factors giving Canada a low murder rate give Wyoming a low murder rate, and that the factors differentiating the rest of America from Wyoming are the same factors that differentiate the rest of America from Canada and Germany, and France….

Still, obedience rule consequentialists can ask what would happen if everybody obeyed a rule or what would happen if everybody violated a rule. You might want to say that I fortunately did the right thing, but that my action was morally wrong.

Such consequentialists do not just add up values; they look at patterns.

Abortion: Morally Permissible or Impermissible

Introduction to Plain Consequentialism There is disagreement about how consequentialism can best be formulated as a precise theory, and so there are various versions of consequentialism.

One common illustration is called Transplant. But some of it is due to easier access to guns. Now, this objection does not directly apply to Plain Consequentialism or Plain Scalar Consequentialism, for these theories do not say that we should think about consequences. Cases like these lead some consequentialists to deny that moral rightness is any function of the values of particular effects of acts.

Fetal Attraction: Abortion and the Principle of Charity

Since it does not seem irrational to refuse to hook oneself up to this machine, hedonism seems inadequate. SingerUngerNorcross Also, when you are about to follow through on a project you have started, you should not stop to calculate the overall consequences anew before you proceed.

One could argue that the historical cause is oppression of women. To find out whether the action is rationally justifiable overall, one must look beyond these specific kinds of reason to find what overall reason there is. And since we ought to do what is rationally justifiable, we ought to do whatever does the most good overall.Abortions: Morally Acceptable or Not?

The issue of abortion is one of the most sensitive and controversial issues faced by modern societies.

Peter Singer

This issue leads to topics of whether abortion is right or wrong, if it is the actual killing of a person, and what actually defines the moral status of a fetus.

You are correct. I am using a reworded form of the SLED test. I was trained by Scott Klusendorf 13 years ago and I generally recommend his material.


Scott is a theist but he nevertheless can make a strong secular case against abortion that has served as fuel to my own. Home > Opinions > Society > Is abortion morally wrong? Add a New Topic. Is abortion morally wrong?

The Nazi Anatomists

I think abortion is morally wrong because you are killing a growing baby. the women doesn’t what the child or cannot provide for the child there are other option out in the world other than just killing a young child who wont get the. I see that David Benatar’s excellent book Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence has just come out in paperback.

It’s almost enough to make me regret that I am on sabbatical this coming year. In my Contemporary Moral Issues course I always teach abortion as the first topic. Indeed, it has been concluded that compulsory population-control laws, even including laws requiring compulsory abortion, could be sustained under the existing Constitution if the population crisis became sufficiently severe to endanger the society.

Many erroneously believe that because a politician claims to be pro-life, he is. Until his candidacy, where there is a public record, Donald Trump and his family have supported child killing.

An analysis of the topic of abortion and the morally just killing
Rated 5/5 based on 9 review